Grape varieties and climate change: which varieties for tomorrow?

Marselan grape bunch
Marselan grape bunch. Photo: Vbecart, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

What changes in the vineyard

Climate change first alters the vine’s calendar. Rising temperatures bring forward budburst, flowering, véraison (the onset of ripening) and ripeness. In most French vineyards, harvests take place markedly earlier than in the mid-20th century, often in August in the Midi.

This earlier timing has knock-on effects:

Why the grape variety is at the heart of the problem

Each grape variety has its own earliness: the number of degree-days it needs to ripen. Historically, vineyards selected varieties that ripened just before the first autumn cold, in the best years. This tension gave Burgundy’s pinot noir or the Loire’s chenin their balance.

When the climate warms, an early variety ripens in the middle of summer heat. Merlot, early and rich in sugar, is often cited among the most exposed varieties in Bordeaux; grenache noir easily produces very high-alcohol wines in the South.

Earliness Examples of varieties on the site Expected effect of warming
Early Pinot noir, chardonnay, merlot, gamay Ripening in full heat, risk of losing freshness
Medium Syrah, cabernet franc, sauvignon blanc Situation varies by region
Late Mourvèdre, carignan, cabernet sauvignon, petit manseng Better placed in regions where they struggled to ripen

This ranking remains indicative: how a variety behaves also depends on soil, rootstock, clone and vine management.

The levers of adaptation

Winegrowers have several levers, from the fastest to the slowest:

  1. cultural practices: canopy management to shade the bunches, grass cover, irrigation where permitted, harvest date;
  2. existing plant material: choosing later clones or clones lower in sugar, and rootstocks that tolerate drought better or delay ripening;
  3. location: planting at altitude, on cooler aspects or on soils that retain water;
  4. the grape variety: changing part of the plantings, drawing on the region’s late varieties, on Mediterranean varieties or on forgotten grapes suited to heat.

Changing grape variety is the heaviest lever: a vineyard is planted for several decades, and in an AOC the list of grape varieties is fixed by the specification.

The adaptation varieties scheme in AOCs

To remove this obstacle, the INAO opened up in the late 2010s the possibility of including varieties of interest for adaptation purposes in appellations. The general rules:

Rule Content
Share in the estate Maximum 5% of the estate’s vineyard area for the appellation
Share in the blend Maximum 10% of the wine
Labelling The name of these grapes cannot appear on the label
Procedure Application by the managing body, amendment of the specification, monitoring and evaluation

This framework makes it possible to experiment in real conditions without changing an appellation’s profile all at once. It applies as much to Mediterranean varieties as to disease-resistant grapes, which address another issue: reducing treatments.

The example of Bordeaux

The Bordeaux vineyard was the first to use this scheme on a large scale. After years of trials, notably on INRAE’s VitAdapt experimental plot, planted in 2009 with several dozen grape varieties, the Bordeaux and Bordeaux supérieur AOCs had seven varieties admitted:

Colour Varieties Origin
Red Arinarnoa INRA breeding
Red Castets Old South-West France grape, almost extinct
Red Marselan INRA breeding, cabernet sauvignon × grenache
Red Touriga nacional Portugal, Douro
White Alvarinho (albariño) Galicia and northern Portugal
White Liliorila INRA breeding
White Petit manseng South-West France, Jurançon

The choice mixes late varieties, varieties from hotter climates and a forgotten local grape. The aim is not to replace merlot or cabernet, but to give them extra room for manoeuvre.

Other appellations have followed comparable approaches, sometimes with resistant grapes such as voltis in Champagne.

Outside the AOCs

PGIs (IGP) and wines without a geographical indication have far greater freedom in their choice of varieties. This is where much of the trial work takes place: Greek, Italian, Spanish or Portuguese varieties in the Languedoc, resistant varieties across France. Some of these grapes could one day enter the AOCs through the adaptation route.

Research avenues

Research is exploring several complementary directions:

What this means for the wine lover

In the short term, the style of wines is changing faster than the grape names on labels: riper, higher-alcohol wines, sometimes corrected by earlier harvests. In the medium term, expect unexpected grapes to appear in blends, often without being mentioned on the label, and a growing place for blends, which make it possible to balance a hot vintage.

Grapes mentioned in this guide

  • Marselan (black, France, Hérault (Languedoc))
  • Touriga nacional (black, Portugal, probably Dão)
  • Petit manseng (white, France, Pyrenean foothills (Béarn, Basque Country))
  • Albariño (white, Spain (Galicia) and northern Portugal)
  • Grenache noir (black, Spain, Aragon (origin disputed with Sardinia))
  • Merlot (black, France, Bordeaux (Libournais))
  • Syrah (black, France, northern Rhône Valley)
  • Voltis (white, France, INRAE (Colmar and Montpellier))

Frequently asked questions

What effects does warming have on grapes?

It brings the vine's stages forward, from budburst to ripeness, and shifts harvests towards hotter periods. Grapes accumulate more sugar, so wines have more alcohol, while acidity falls. Aromas can shift towards riper notes, and drought or late frost become major risks.

What is a variety of interest for adaptation purposes?

It is a variety that does not belong to an AOC's traditional list of grape varieties but can be introduced into it to cope with climate change. The scheme overseen by the INAO limits its share to 5% of the estate's plantings and 10% of the blend, and naming the grape on the label is not allowed.

Which new grapes has Bordeaux authorised?

The Bordeaux and Bordeaux supérieur AOCs had seven adaptation varieties admitted in the early 2020s: arinarnoa, castets, marselan and touriga nacional among the reds, alvarinho, liliorila and petit manseng among the whites. They remain minority varieties and are subject to the scheme's ceilings.

Will climate change move vineyards northwards?

Regions that were once too cool, such as southern England, now produce recognised wines, and vines are moving up in altitude. But historic vineyards adapt first on the spot, through the choice of varieties, clones, rootstocks and cultural practices.