Rootstocks and phylloxera: the European vine on American roots

Phylloxera, an aphid from America
Phylloxera (Daktulosphaira vitifoliae) is an insect of the aphid family, native to the east of North America. It lives on American vines, which evolved with it and tolerate it. On the European vine, Vitis vinifera, it is deadly: it pierces the roots, causes swellings and then lesions where rots set in, and the vine declines within a few years.
It was introduced into Europe in the mid-19th century, probably with American vine plants imported for collections or to fight powdery mildew. The first damage was observed in the Gard in the early 1860s, and the insect was identified in 1868 by a Montpellier commission in which Jules-Émile Planchon took part.
The phylloxera crisis
In a few decades, phylloxera reached almost the whole French vineyard, then the European one. The consequences were considerable:
- disappearance of most of the French vines;
- a fall in production, wine imports and the spread of fraud;
- rural exodus in some wine regions;
- definitive loss of many local grapes that were not replanted.
This last consequence explains why so many old grapes survive only in collections (see forgotten grapes of South-West France and grape variety conservatories).
The solutions tried
Several remedies were tried before grafting took hold.
| Solution | Principle | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Flooding | Flood the vines in winter to drown the insect | Possible only on irrigable plains |
| Chemical treatments | Injection of carbon disulphide into the soil | Costly, to be repeated, toxic |
| Planting in sand | Phylloxera does not survive in very sandy soils | Limited areas, mostly on the coast |
| Direct-producer hybrids | Cross American and European vines to obtain a resistant grape | Wine quality judged insufficient, then bans |
| Grafting | European grape variety grafted onto American root | The solution adopted, still in force |
The direct-producer hybrids, such as noah, clinton, jacquez or isabelle, were widely spread before being fought and then banned for commercial wine production (see banned hybrids (1934)).
Grafting: the lasting solution
The principle is simple: two plants are joined. The scion, a piece of shoot of the European grape variety, gives the leaves and the grapes. The rootstock, derived from resistant American species, gives the roots. Phylloxera can pierce these roots, but they heal and do not die.
Grafting took hold in the 1880s, driven notably by researchers in Montpellier. American species suited to European soils had to be found. The first ones used, Vitis riparia and Vitis rupestris, coped poorly with chalky soils, very common in France. In 1887, Pierre Viala was sent to the United States and came back with the idea of using Vitis berlandieri, a Texan species that tolerates lime but is hard to propagate by cuttings. The solution came through crosses between species.
The main rootstocks
A rootstock generally has a name and a number, those of the breeder and of the selected seedling. The most common in France:
| Rootstock | Genetic origin | Main characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| Riparia Gloire de Montpellier | V. riparia | Low vigour, advances the cycle, dislikes lime and drought |
| Rupestris du Lot | V. rupestris | Strong vigour, poor and stony soils |
| 3309 C | V. riparia × V. rupestris | Moderate vigour, deep, cool soils low in lime |
| 101-14 MGt | V. riparia × V. rupestris | Earliness, cool and fertile soils |
| SO4 | V. berlandieri × V. riparia | Vigour, average tolerance to lime, very widespread |
| 161-49 C | V. riparia × V. berlandieri | Good tolerance to lime, moderate vigour |
| 41 B | Chasselas × V. berlandieri | High tolerance to lime, used in Champagne and Cognac |
| Fercal | V. berlandieri-based hybrid | Very high tolerance to lime |
| 110 R | V. berlandieri × V. rupestris | Drought tolerance, the Midi |
| 140 Ru | V. berlandieri × V. rupestris | High vigour, drought tolerance |
| 1103 P | V. berlandieri × V. rupestris | Vigour, drought, widely planted worldwide |
| Gravesac | Bordeaux breeding | Acidic and gravelly soils |
The letters refer to the breeders: C for Couderc, MGt for Millardet and de Grasset, R for Richter, Ru for Ruggeri, P for Paulsen. 41 B contains chasselas: it is therefore partly European, which explains a phylloxera resistance judged sufficient but less absolute.
How a rootstock is chosen
The choice is made plot by plot. The main criteria:
- the active lime in the soil, which causes chlorosis (yellowing of the leaves) on poorly tolerant rootstocks;
- the water reserve and the risk of drought;
- the desired vigour: a vigorous rootstock on a rich soil gives too much foliage and yield;
- the cycle: some rootstocks advance ripeness, others delay it, a useful lever in the face of climate change;
- nematodes and salinity, in some soils;
- the affinity with the grafted grape variety.
The rootstock and the clone are chosen together: they are the two components of the “planting material” of a vineyard.
Own-rooted vines
An own-rooted vine is not grafted: it grows on its own roots. They can still be found:
- in sand: the Languedoc coast, near Aigues-Mortes, and other sandy soils where phylloxera does not survive;
- in isolated plots, sometimes very old, in France and Europe;
- in spared countries: Chile, protected by its natural barriers, grows many ungrafted vines, including país and carménère.
Wines from own-rooted vines attract growing interest, but no systematic difference in taste has been demonstrated: the soil and the age of the vines probably count for more.
Phylloxera today
Phylloxera has not disappeared: it is present in the soils of most vineyards. It remains contained by rootstocks. Vineyards that planted insufficiently resistant rootstocks learned this at their own expense: California suffered a new crisis in the 1980s and 1990s with the AxR1 rootstock, which had vinifera among its origins.
The lesson has stuck: every European vine planted on a non-sandy soil must be grafted onto a proven rootstock of American origin.
Grapes mentioned in this guide
- Chasselas (white, Switzerland, west of the country (Lake Geneva region))
- Noah (white, United States, Illinois)
- Clinton (black, United States, New York State)
- Jacquez (black, Southern United States (exact origin uncertain))
- Isabella (black, United States, South Carolina (probable origin))
- Carménère (black, France, Bordeaux area)
- País (Listán prieto) (black, Spain, Castile)
Frequently asked questions
What is phylloxera?
It is a small insect of the aphid family, native to North America. On the European vine, it pierces the roots and causes lesions that end up killing the vine within a few years. American vines, which evolved with it, tolerate it.
Why is the vine grafted?
To protect it from phylloxera. A European grape variety, which gives the fruit, is joined to a rootstock derived from American species, which forms the roots. The aphid can no longer destroy the root system, and the grape keeps the qualities of the grafted variety.
Are there ungrafted vines?
Yes, but they are rare. Phylloxera does not survive in very sandy soils, where own-rooted vines are found, for example on the Languedoc coast. Some countries, such as Chile, were largely spared and still grow many ungrafted vines.
Does the rootstock change the taste of the wine?
Indirectly. The rootstock does not transmit aromas, but it influences the vigour of the vine, the yield, the date of ripeness and the water supply. These effects change the composition of the grape and therefore the wine.