Resistant grapes: what the regulations really say

Souvignier gris grape bunch
Souvignier gris grape bunch. Photo: Thorbjoern.Joerger, CC BY-SA 3.0 de, via Wikimedia Commons.

Definition: what a resistant grape is

A resistant grape is a vine variety selected to tolerate the two major fungal diseases imported from America in the 19th century, downy mildew and powdery mildew, thanks to resistance genes from non-vinifera species. These genes come from American vines (notably Vitis rupestris, V. aestivalis), Asian vines (V. amurensis) or Muscadinia rotundifolia.

The term is regulatorily vague: one also hears “resistant varieties”, “VDR” or “PIWI” (a German abbreviation). It refers to recent breeds, obtained by successive backcrosses with vinifera, and not to the direct-producer hybrids of the late 19th century.

Three regulatory levels

A resistant grape’s access to the market is decided at three levels, which must be distinguished.

Level Who decides What the variety obtains
Classification as a wine grape Member State (FranceAgriMer, order) Right to produce wine without a geographical indication
PGI specification ODG and INAO Claim of the PGI (IGP)
AOC specification ODG and INAO, VIFA scheme Claim of the AOC, with ceilings

European law

Article 81 of Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013 authorises the classification of varieties belonging to Vitis vinifera or coming from a cross between this species and other species of the genus Vitis, with the exception of six named varieties. Resistant grapes fall into this second category: they are classifiable.

Until 2021, however, the European definition of a designation of origin required wines to be made exclusively from Vitis vinifera. Regulation (EU) 2021/2117 changed this definition: a PDO can now be made from varieties of Vitis vinifera or coming from a cross between that species and other species of the genus Vitis. The regulation’s recital justifies this by climate adaptation and disease resistance.

French law

National classification is either permanent or temporary, on a file examined by FranceAgriMer (see the official catalogue of vine varieties). Temporary classification served as the entry point for many foreign varieties, confined to monitored experimental plots.

INRAE’s ResDur programme

INRAE embarked in 2000 on a programme to create varieties with durable resistance, known as ResDur. Its principle: combine several resistance genes (polygenic resistance) to prevent the fungus from overcoming a single resistance, as has happened with some monogenic varieties.

In January 2018, four varieties from the first series were registered in the official catalogue:

Variety Colour Parentage (according to INRAE) Resistances
Artaban N Mtp 3082-1-42 × Regent Rpv1 + Rpv3 (downy mildew), Run1 + Ren3 (powdery mildew)
Vidoc N Mtp 3082-1-42 × Regent same
Voltis B Villaris × Mtp 3159-2-12 same
Floreal B Villaris × Mtp 3159-2-12 same

The “Mtp” lines were selected by Alain Bouquet in Montpellier by introgressing the resistance of Muscadinia rotundifolia; regent and Villaris come from the German Julius Kühn Institute (Geilweilerhof). Artaban and Vidoc were co-bred with that institute.

INRAE stresses a point that is often forgotten: these varieties do not remove the need for all protection. A few complementary treatments are recommended to preserve the resistances and against black rot. The fungicide saving is estimated at between 80 and 90%.

The VIFA scheme: the gateway to AOCs

The VIFA scheme (varieties of interest for adaptation purposes) allows a defence and management body (ODG) to include in its specification, on an experimental basis, varieties absent from its traditional list of grape varieties. It is not reserved for resistant grapes: it is also used for climate change, alcohol reduction or the rehabilitation of local grapes.

The INAO directive of 3 June 2021 sets its rules:

At the end of the evaluation, the national committee decides whether each variety becomes an accessory, complementary or principal grape, or is withdrawn.

Practical consequence: within this framework, an AOC wine cannot be a pure resistant-grape wine. The variety remains a minority and is blended in.

PGIs, the main ground for resistant varieties

PGIs have more flexible specifications, which often list long series of varieties. This is where single-variety wines of souvignier gris, solaris or ResDur varieties are concentrated. Each PGI decides its own list; it must be checked variety by variety.

Wines without a geographical indication remain the other outlet: any classified variety can be vinified there, and the grape name can appear on the label subject to certification (see grape names on the label).

Resistant grapes, banned hybrids: where does the line fall?

The line is legal, not genetic. Noah or jacquez are interspecific hybrids like modern resistant grapes, but they are expressly excluded from classification by European law. The “wine package” adopted in 2026 (Regulation (EU) 2026/471) did not change this list.

Criterion Banned hybrids Modern resistant grapes
Origin Spontaneous or 19th-century crosses Breeding programmes since the late 20th century
Share of vinifera Variable, often low High after backcrossing
EU status Expressly excluded from classification Classifiable
PDO (AOP) Impossible Possible since 2021, via the specifications

Points of attention for the reader

For the climate dimension of the subject, see grape varieties and climate change and the list of resistant grapes on the site.

Grapes mentioned in this guide

  • Souvignier gris (pink, Germany, Baden (Freiburg viticulture institute))
  • Regent (black, Germany, Pfalz (Geilweilerhof institute, Siebeldingen))
  • Solaris (white, Germany, Baden (Freiburg viticulture institute))
  • Artaban (black, France, INRAE (Colmar and Montpellier), with the JKI (Germany))
  • Vidoc (black, France, INRAE (Colmar and Montpellier), with the JKI (Germany))
  • Voltis (white, France, INRAE (Colmar and Montpellier))
  • Floréal (white, France, INRAE (Colmar and Montpellier))
  • Noah (white, United States, Illinois)

Frequently asked questions

Is a resistant grape a hybrid?

Genetically, yes: it descends from crosses between Vitis vinifera and American or Asian vines, or even Muscadinia rotundifolia. But modern varieties have been backcrossed for several generations with vinifera, and European law treats them as classifiable varieties, unlike the six banned direct-producer hybrids.

Can an AOC be made with a resistant grape?

European law has allowed it since Regulation (EU) 2021/2117, which authorises PDOs made from crosses between Vitis vinifera and other species of the genus Vitis. In practice, the variety must appear in the appellation's specification, generally as a VIFA, within the limit of 5% of the estate's plantings and 10% of the final blend.

Which resistant grapes were bred by INRAE?

The ResDur programme, launched in 2000, led in January 2018 to the registration in the catalogue of four varieties: Artaban and Vidoc (black), Voltis and Floreal (white). They combine two resistance factors to downy mildew (Rpv1 and Rpv3) and two to powdery mildew (Run1 and Ren3).

Does a resistant grape need no treatment at all?

No. INRAE recommends a few complementary fungicide treatments to preserve the durability of the resistances and to protect against black rot, to which Artaban, for example, is susceptible. The fungicide saving announced for these varieties is between 80 and 90%.

Sources

  1. INAO, directive INAO-DIR-CNAOV-2018-01 rev2 on varieties of interest for adaptation purposes (3 June 2021) (in French)
  2. Regulation (EU) 2021/2117 amending Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013, EUR-Lex (in French)
  3. INRAE, variety sheets for the ResDur varieties Artaban, Floreal, Vidoc and Voltis (in French)