Pinot gris or pinot grigio: what is the difference?

Pinot gris grape bunch
Pinot gris grape bunch. Photo: Andy / Andrew Fogg, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Pinot gris and Pinot grigio: side-by-side comparison

CriterionPinot grisPinot grigio
NatureFrench name of the grapeItalian name of the same grape
OriginBurgundy, colour mutation of pinot noirIdentical
Berry colourPinkish-grey to coppery brown (code G)Identical
Typical harvest timeAdvanced ripeness, sometimes overripenessEarly harvest to preserve liveliness
AromasPear, quince, dried fruit, honey, smoke, undergrowthGreen apple, lemon, white flowers, almond
StructureFull, rich, often high alcohol, dry to sweetLight, lively, dry, moderate alcohol
RegionsAlsace, Germany, Oregon, New ZealandVeneto, Friuli-Venezia Giulia, Trentino-Alto Adige
Flagship appellationsAlsace, Alsace grand cru, vendanges tardives, sélection de grains noblesDOC delle Venezie, Friuli, Trentino, Alto Adige
AgeingSeveral years for the grands crus and sweet winesGenerally to be drunk young
Food pairingsPoultry in cream sauce, foie gras, smoked or spicy cookingAperitif, grilled fish, salads, antipasti

Verdict: one grape, two styles

Pinot gris and pinot grigio refer to the same grape. Yet the label announces two different wines: the “gris” style, inspired by Alsace, is rich, spicy, sometimes sweet; the “grigio” style, inspired by Italy, is light, lively and dry. The name therefore tells you less about the grape than about how it was grown and made.

A mutation of pinot noir

Pinot gris is not genetically distinct from pinot noir: it is a colour mutation. Its DNA is almost identical; only the pigmentation of the skin differs. Pinot blanc is another mutation of the same family. The guide colour mutations explains this phenomenon.

Known in Burgundy since the Middle Ages, pinot gris spread to central Europe. In Germany it is called grauburgunder or ruländer, in Hungary szürkebarát.

The pinot gris style: ripeness and richness

In Alsace, pinot gris is one of the four traditional grand cru grapes. It is picked at good ripeness, even overripe for the vendanges tardives and sélection de grains nobles designations. The wines are full and rich, with aromas of pear, quince, dried fruit and smoke. They can be dry, off-dry or sweet.

This style is found in Germany (Baden), Oregon and New Zealand, where producers readily use the name pinot gris.

The pinot grigio style: freshness and lightness

In north-eastern Italy (Veneto, Friuli, Trentino-Alto Adige), pinot grigio is harvested earlier to preserve acidity. The wines are light and dry, with discreet aromas of green apple, citrus and white flowers. They are drunk young.

The commercial success of pinot grigio, notably for export, led to the creation in 2017 of the DOC delle Venezie, which regulates a large part of production.

Some Friuli growers also make ramato, a skin maceration that gives the wine a coppery tint.

The differences that matter

Factor Effect on the wine
Harvest date Late: richness and sugar; early: liveliness
Yield Low: concentration; high: lightness
Climate Dry, sunny Alsace: ripeness; Italian plains: volume
Skin contact Direct pressing: white wine; maceration: coppery tint

When to choose one or the other

Choose an Alsace pinot gris to accompany rich cooking: poultry in cream sauce, mushrooms, foie gras (for the sweet versions) or smoked and lightly spiced dishes.

Choose a pinot grigio for an aperitif, a salad, grilled fish or antipasti: a simple, fresh, thirst-quenching white.

For other questions of misleading names, see synonyms and homonyms. For another case of a single grape under two names, see syrah or shiraz.

Frequently asked questions

Are pinot grigio and pinot gris the same grape?

Yes. Grigio means "grey" in Italian. The grape is identical; it is the harvesting and winemaking choices that produce two distinct styles. New World producers use one name or the other depending on the style they are aiming for.

Is pinot gris a white wine?

Yes, almost always. Its berries are pinkish-grey, but the juice is colourless. Pressed quickly, it makes a white wine, sometimes slightly golden or coppery. Maceration on the skins, on the other hand, gives a pink-tinted wine, the "ramato" of the Italians.

Why was Alsace pinot gris called tokay?

It was long sold under the name "tokay d'Alsace" or "tokay pinot gris". This name was abandoned in 2007 under European rules, the name tokaji being reserved for the Hungarian wine.

What is the difference from pinot blanc?

Pinot blanc and pinot gris are both colour mutations of pinot noir. Pinot blanc has golden berries and makes more neutral, lighter wines; pinot gris, with grey berries, makes richer, more aromatic wines.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (EN), "Pinot gris"
  2. Conseil interprofessionnel des vins d'Alsace (CIVA) (in French)