Ampelography: how a grape variety is recognised in the vineyard

Pinot meunier grape bunch
Pinot meunier grape bunch. Photo: Igor Zemljič (IgorvonLenart at sl.wikipedia), Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.

Definition

Ampelography is the science that describes and identifies vine varieties from their visible characters. The word comes from the Greek ampelos, the vine, and graphein, to describe. An ampelographer can tell, in front of a vine, which variety it is, or at least which one it is not.

It meets a practical need: grape varieties have been propagated by cuttings for centuries, names change from one region to another (see synonyms and homonyms) and planting errors are frequent. Objective criteria are therefore needed to know what is being planted.

A discipline born of the crises of the 19th century

Modern ampelography developed in the 19th century, when European vineyards had to be rebuilt after powdery mildew and then phylloxera (see rootstocks and phylloxera). Grape varieties had to be inventoried, American rootstocks and hybrids described, and confusion in nurseries avoided.

The great work of that period is the Ampélographie edited by Pierre Viala and Victor Vermorel, published in several volumes at the start of the 20th century, with colour plates that remain famous.

In the 20th century, Pierre Galet (1921-2019), in Montpellier, systematised the method. He proposed an identification based on measurements of the adult leaf (ampelometry) and described thousands of varieties. His dictionary of grape varieties remains a reference work.

The organs observed

Identification never rests on a single character. Several organs are examined, at precise stages of the cycle.

Organ Stage of observation What is looked at
Tip of the young shoot In spring, growing shoot Opening, hairiness (density of prostrate or erect hairs), pigmentation
Young leaf First unfolded leaves Colour, hairiness, bronzed or green appearance
Adult leaf Summer, leaf from the middle of the shoot Shape, lobes, sinuses, teeth, hairiness, blistering
Shoot Summer and winter (cane) Colour, cross-section, internodes
Flower Flowering Sex of the flower (hermaphrodite or female)
Bunch Ripeness Size, compactness, shape, wings
Berry Ripeness Shape, size, colour, skin thickness, flavour, flesh colour
Seed Ripeness Shape, size, number

The tip of the young shoot

This is one of the most discriminating criteria. The tip of the shoot can be hairless, cottony or downy, more or less tinged with pink or bronze. Pinot meunier is the illustration: its very downy tip, as if dusted with flour, gave it its name.

The adult leaf

The leaf is the most studied organ. The main criteria:

The deeply cut leaf of cabernet sauvignon, with deep sinuses often pierced by rounded “holes”, is easily told apart from the more entire leaf of chardonnay, whose petiolar sinus has a characteristic base that is bare along the veins.

The bunch and the berry

The bunch and the berry confirm identification at harvest. A small, compact bunch, a round or ellipsoid berry, a thin or thick skin, a neutral, muscat or foxy flavour (the taste of American hybrids, see hybrids banned in 1934): each character narrows the field of possibilities. The colour of the flesh immediately distinguishes a teinturier.

The OIV descriptors

So that descriptions can be compared from one country to another, the International Organisation of Vine and Wine (OIV) publishes a list of coded descriptors. Each character receives a code and a scale of scores (for example, hairiness absent, low, medium, high, very high).

These descriptors are used:

Classic confusions

Some pairs of grape varieties are hard to tell apart by eye:

Pair Difficulty What helps
Merlot and carménère Similar leaves; massive confusion in Chile until 1994 Young leaves and later ripening of carménère
Chardonnay and pinot blanc Long mixed up in Burgundy Petiolar sinus of chardonnay, veins bare at the base
Colour forms (pinot noir, gris, blanc) Identical leaves Only the ripe berry tells them apart (see colour mutations)
Clones of the same variety Minimal differences Agronomic observations, no reliable visual identification

The merlot-carménère confusion, identified by the ampelographer Jean-Michel Boursiquot, shows that a trained eye can correct errors more than a century old.

Ampelography and DNA

Since the 1990s, DNA analysis with microsatellite markers has made it possible to identify a grape variety with great certainty from a leaf fragment (see DNA parentage of grape varieties). It has solved many puzzles, but it does not make ampelography useless:

The two approaches complement each other: ampelography formulates a hypothesis, DNA confirms it, and the conservatories keep the reference vines used by both.

To practise

Observing a known grape variety over a season is the best school: note the appearance of the young shoot in May, draw an adult leaf in July, compare the bunch at harvest. By comparing two neighbouring varieties, for example sauvignon blanc and chasselas, the criteria quickly become familiar.

Grapes mentioned in this guide

Frequently asked questions

What is ampelography?

It is the discipline that describes and identifies vine varieties from their morphological characters: leaves, shoots, bunches, berries, seeds. The word comes from the Greek ampelos, the vine. It is used to check the identity of vines, to describe new varieties and to rediscover forgotten grapes.

How do you recognise a grape variety from its leaf?

You look at the adult leaf, taken from the middle of the shoot: number of lobes, depth of the lateral sinuses, shape of the petiolar sinus (open, closed, overlapping), shape and size of the teeth, hairiness of the underside. One leaf is not enough: several leaves and other organs are examined.

Who was Pierre Galet?

Pierre Galet (1921-2019) was a French ampelographer who taught in Montpellier. He developed an identification method based on measurements of the leaf. His books, including an encyclopaedic dictionary of grape varieties, are world references.

Has DNA replaced ampelography?

No. DNA gives a reliable identity from a sample, but you first need to know what to sample and to spot suspect vines in the vineyard. Ampelography remains essential in the field, in nurseries and for describing the agronomic characters that DNA does not show.

Sources

  1. Wikipedia (in French), "Ampélographie"
  2. Wikipedia (in French), "Pierre Galet"