# Othello: the Canadian hybrid among the six banned grapes

Source: https://cepages.info/en/grapes/othello/
Updated: 2026-11-19

> Othello is a black hybrid grape (N) bred in 1859 in Ontario (Canada) by the breeder Charles Arnold, crossing the American clinton with black hamburg, a European grape also called frankenthal or schiava grossa. It is one of the six hybrids banned in France by the 1934-1935 legislation, and European law still excludes it from wine grape varieties. It has served as a parent to other hybrids.

- Colour: Black grape (N)
- Status: Direct producer hybrid
- Origin: Canada, Ontario
- Parentage: Clinton × Black Hamburg (frankenthal); bred by Charles Arnold in 1859
- Synonyms: Arnold 1, Arnold's Hybrid, Canadian Hamburg, Canadian Hybrid

- VIVC: 8838
- Wikidata: Q1226941

## Origin: a hybrid created in Canada

Othello is one of the first **deliberately bred hybrids** in North America. It was created in **1859** in **Ontario**, Canada, by the private breeder **Charles Arnold**, hence its synonyms "Arnold 1", "Arnold's Hybrid" and "Canadian Hamburg".

Unlike [clinton](/en/grapes/clinton/) or [noah](/en/grapes/noah/), born from American vines, othello deliberately combines an American vine and a European grape, in the hope of combining the hardiness of the former with the quality of the latter.

## Parentage

| Parent | Nature | Note |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Clinton | American hybrid (*V. riparia* × *V. labrusca*) | Brings resistance and the foxy flavour |
| Black hamburg | *Vitis vinifera* | Also called frankenthal, trollinger or schiava grossa |

The INRAE genetic resources register also gives the parentage "Clinton × Black Hambourg" and attributes it to Arnold. The name "black hamburg" is ambiguous: in English-speaking countries it also designates [muscat of Hamburg](/en/grapes/muscat-de-hambourg/), which descends precisely from frankenthal. Such name confusions are frequent, see the guide on [synonyms and homonyms](/en/guides/synonyms-and-homonyms/).

Othello has itself served as a parent to other hybrids, such as folle america and gaillard 2.

## In France: from direct producer to ban

Othello was planted in France as a **direct-producer hybrid** in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, when growers were looking for vines able to produce without grafting after phylloxera. It is one of the **six grapes** banned by the 1934-1935 legislation:

- [noah](/en/grapes/noah/);
- [clinton](/en/grapes/clinton/);
- [isabelle](/en/grapes/isabelle/);
- [jacquez](/en/grapes/jacquez/);
- [herbemont](/en/grapes/herbemont/);
- othello.

The measure cited the mediocre quality of these wines and their methanol content, in a context of heavy overproduction. The guide on [the banned hybrids of 1934](/en/guides/hybrids-banned-in-1934/) traces the background to this decision.

## Current status

Articles 95 and 96 of the French wine code, which targeted these grapes, were repealed in 2003. But the ban was taken up at European level: the 2008 regulation on the common organisation of the wine market, then **Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013**, prohibit classifying othello as a wine grape variety. Its wine therefore cannot be marketed under the name "wine", even though family production remains tolerated.

In Austria, othello has been used for **Uhudler**, a speciality of southern Burgenland made from American hybrid grapes.

The debate on rehabilitating the six banned grapes was revived in the European Parliament in 2025. At the date this page was last updated, no definitive lifting of the ban could be confirmed. The other varieties of this family are grouped on the page [direct-producer hybrids](/en/grapes/direct-producer-hybrids/).

## The wine

Othello wine is **red**. Like that of the other first-generation hybrids, it was mainly produced for **family consumption**, in regions of small-scale viticulture where the hardiness of the vine mattered more than the finesse of the wine. Reliable tasting descriptions are rare, for lack of commercial production for almost a century.

## Frequently asked questions

### Who are the parents of othello?

Othello comes from a cross between clinton, an American hybrid of Vitis riparia and Vitis labrusca, and black hamburg, a European table grape also known as frankenthal, trollinger or schiava grossa. It is therefore a hybrid between an American vine and Vitis vinifera.

### Is othello banned?

Yes, in the sense that its wine cannot be marketed as "wine" in the European Union. It is one of the six grapes banned in France in 1934-1935, and Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013 still prohibits classifying it as a wine grape variety.

### Is othello related to muscat of Hamburg?

Indirectly. Black hamburg (frankenthal), one of the parents of othello, is also one of the presumed parents of muscat of Hamburg. The two grapes therefore share a European ancestor, but othello is an interspecific hybrid whereas muscat of Hamburg is a pure vinifera.
